Besides being governed by logical axioms as all things could only be, what do credit scores, academic institutions, corporations, grammar, fashion styles, currencies, legal marriages, and other such things have in common? They are all social constructs, like normalized mealtimes and arbitrary holidays. A social construct must be invented or practiced by people to exist. One way or another, it cannot exist on its own, since it requires a community of conscious beings in order to be brought about. A lone person, were they the only one alive, could certainly decide at random to create a calendar system or a language; some things, however, like economies and legal marriages, logically necessitate that at least two people do something in order for them to exist.
Other social constructs of a different type would include gender and racial stereotypes, though these are false philosophical beliefs about people because of the appearance (or with gender, the corresponding physiology) of their physical body. A stereotype, though it is false by logical necessity, is not the same kind of social construct as tangible money, which is created from materials in the natural world or literally is something taken from nature that is used as a currency unprocessed (i.e., cattle). It is also different from something like a human language, which is not false and does not exist out in the world to be harnessed for societal use. Language can be written on physical things, but it is not physical.
As briefly addressed, some social constructs can only be false. Gender stereotypes are assumed ideas about a mental trait or moral obligation being somehow connected to the physical genitalia, though one does not follow from the other and two people of the same gender do not necessarily have the same personality; their gender is irrelevant. Other social constructs such as currency can be real in one sense, though they are artificially contrived by default. One category is that of erroneous ideas and the other is that of things that, while they can be real on a certain level, have to be created. Thus, either kind of social construct cannot be supremely foundational.
It can only be true that a social construct, by virtue of being something that must be created by already existing beings and (in certain cases) something that is necessarily erroneous, cannot be among the most foundational aspects of reality. Take the example of a holiday like Independence Day. An annual nationwide celebration during daylight hours relies on the more fundamental day-night cycle tied to the natural world's celestial bodies, but even the very possibility of the natural world and its patterns existing depends wholly on being consistent with the necessary truths of logical axioms and what follows from them.
It is not that the physical world is the real heart of reality just because the materials for the constructs of buildings and tangible currencies and so on are derived from it, or because it is what calendars and holidays are tied to. A social construct like legal marriage is not even a physical thing at all since it is a relational status shared by minds, but the legal aspects of a human society are still mere social constructs all the same. However, since logical axioms and other necessary truths cannot be false, as their falsity would still require their veracity, only reason alone could be the core of all reality and true in itself; everything else must be consistent with it to even be possible.
Instead of living accordingly, non-rationalists, if they do not live for subjectivist fallacies in an individualistic way and thus in dismissal of society, live for something like career or legal marriage or reputation, being entirely oblivious or apathetic to the fact that the likes of money, academic traditions, and contrived ceremony are invented and have no authority on their own. Driven by arbitrary contentment with social norms set up contrary to these truths (such as pressuring people to have high-paying jobs just to convince onlookers to respect you as a human), or even by a direct desire to please other people, they are stupid and, as a consequence, also superficial and weak. They live for things that do not matter or that have no inherent truth and they are slaves to whatever predominant beliefs and practices of their day strike them as persuasive and emotionally satisfying.
No comments:
Post a Comment